Pilates instructor listening attentively to a participant in a quiet studio entrance

Responding to Negative Feedback About Your Fitness Class

Share this post on:

A participant waits until everyone else has left, then tells you the class was disappointing. You thought the session had gone well. Your first instinct might be to explain your choices, apologise for everything or replay the conversation for the rest of the day.

Responding to negative feedback about a fitness class starts with a smaller task: understand what the person is actually telling you. You can listen carefully without accepting every interpretation, and take a concern seriously without promising a solution you cannot deliver.

This guide is for Pilates and group fitness instructors handling ordinary teaching and service feedback. The examples are hypothetical. Concerns about injury, harassment, discrimination, unwanted contact or immediate danger need the relevant reporting or emergency process, rather than being treated as a disagreement about class style.

Find out what happened before defending the class

“That wasn’t what I expected” leaves several possibilities open. The person might have expected more individual attention, disliked the music, been unable to hear you or booked a class whose description did not match the experience. Each calls for a different response.

Try: “Could you tell me which part felt different from what you expected?” Then let them finish. If they have already explained clearly, do not make them repeat the whole story just because you have a favourite feedback question.

Reflect the specific concern: “You expected a slower introduction, and felt we moved into the sequence before you understood it.” That is more useful than “I’m sorry you feel that way”, which does little to show what you understood.

Choose the setting with care. A crowded reception desk is a poor place to discuss something personal. Offer a quieter conversation or an appropriate contact route, while recognising that the participant may prefer to write. If another class is waiting, agree a realistic time to respond; do not continue an unfinished conversation while supervising a new group.

Business Queensland’s complaint-handling guidance recommends listening, establishing the outcome the customer wants and making responsibility for resolution clear. The examples below show how those principles can help you respond to a class concern.

Work out what kind of response the concern needs

A preference can be legitimate without requiring you to redesign the whole class. Suppose a participant dislikes music in a session accurately described as a music-led workout. You can acknowledge that preference and explain the format. If a quieter option genuinely exists, describe it accurately; do not invent an alternative simply to end the conversation.

A mismatch between the booking description and the delivered class is different. If a session advertised as an introduction assumes that everyone already knows the exercises, telling a newcomer to book elsewhere avoids the actual issue. Check the wording and discuss both the description and teaching approach with whoever controls them. Our guide to writing a clear fitness class description can help with that review.

An access or communication difficulty also deserves more than a preference label. “I couldn’t hear the instructions” is information about someone’s ability to participate. Ask which parts were difficult and what would help, then consider changes within your role and the venue’s arrangements. Avoid deciding that someone is simply “not suited” to the class before understanding the barrier.

A report about unsafe equipment or inappropriate conduct needs the designated process promptly. Do not investigate serious allegations through informal conversations with other participants, or promise absolute secrecy when reporting duties may apply. Explain who needs to receive the concern and what the person can expect next, using the actual procedure where you teach.

A completed example: when the class promise was unclear

Imagine a fictional instructor, Morgan, receiving this feedback from Sam after a mat class: “The booking page said beginners were welcome, but I didn’t know what half the exercise names meant. I spent most of the class watching everyone else.”

Morgan remembers offering easier movement options. That does not answer Sam’s point: an easier option is not necessarily an understandable instruction. Morgan asks whether there was a particular example. Sam mentions being told to move into a named position without an explanation of where to start.

A useful immediate response could be:

“Thank you for explaining that. I offered movement options, but that didn’t help you understand the starting positions. I’ll review how I introduce those exercises and check the beginners wording with the class coordinator. Would you prefer an email update? I can contact you by Thursday afternoon.”

Choose a follow-up time you can meet. If Sam asks for a refund, Morgan needs to refer that request to the person authorised to decide it rather than casually promising or refusing one.

Before the next class, Morgan identifies three unfamiliar exercise names in the plan. For each, they write a brief starting-position explanation, then practise saying it without relying on the exercise name alone. They ask the coordinator whether the booking description reflects the level of instruction the class can provide.

This is a more targeted response than making the entire session slower. The issue was assumed knowledge. Experienced participants can still receive a purposeful class while newcomers are told what the words mean.

A follow-up, once those actions have actually happened, might read:

“Hi Sam, I’ve revised the introductions for the exercises you mentioned so I explain the starting position before using the exercise name. I’ve also passed your feedback about the booking description to the coordinator, who is reviewing that wording. That part is still pending. Thank you for helping me understand where the class was difficult to follow. Morgan.”

Notice the distinction between completed work and a pending decision. Morgan does not claim the problem is solved, ask Sam to praise the response or require another booking to prove that the feedback was taken seriously.

When you disagree, explain the decision without arguing

Now consider a contrasting example. A regular participant wants every exercise to be more demanding. The class is advertised as a mixed-experience session, and other participants use the existing options.

The instructor can say: “I understand you’d like more challenge. This session includes different experience levels, so I won’t make the most demanding option compulsory. Let’s discuss which of the available options match what you’re looking for.” Any option offered still needs to fit the instructor’s training, the participant and the class setting.

You do not need a majority vote to justify that decision. “Nobody else complained” tells the person that their concern counts only if others repeat it. Equally, one strong opinion does not establish what the whole group needs.

If the account differs from your recollection, separate the known details from what remains uncertain: “I remember giving that instruction, but I can’t tell from here whether it was audible where you were standing.” That leaves room to investigate without pretending you can reconstruct every moment perfectly.

Keep public replies brief and private details private

A critical online review can make a detailed rebuttal tempting. Resist listing the participant’s attendance history, personal circumstances or conversations to demonstrate that your version is correct. A public exchange is rarely the right place to resolve individual teaching needs.

For ordinary service feedback, a concise reply might be: “Thank you for raising your concern about the class instructions. We’d like to understand what happened and discuss it with you. Please use the contact details on our website so the appropriate person can respond.” Adapt this only to a real, monitored contact route and the business’s response arrangements.

Do not post a response on the business’s behalf unless that is part of your role. Send the concern to the appropriate person instead. You can also set boundaries around threatening or abusive behaviour while ensuring the substance of a complaint reaches the proper process.

Review the teaching issue without judging the person

For an ordinary teaching concern, your post-class notes can distinguish what was reported, what you observed and what you plan to review. Keep any formal complaint record in the designated system; a personal planning notebook is not a substitute.

In Morgan’s example, the teaching note could read: “Participant reported unfamiliar exercise names. Add starting-position explanations for three exercises. At the next session, observe whether people can find the position after the first explanation; note where further clarification is needed.” This describes a teaching question without labelling Sam as difficult.

Review what happens next rather than assuming that a rewritten plan has fixed the issue. If instructions remain hard to follow, the amount of information, demonstration or room arrangement may need further attention. For routine feedback collection outside a complaint, see asking for useful class feedback.

A considered response does not guarantee agreement. It does mean the participant’s concern has been understood, you have explained your decision and someone is responsible for each promised action. Those are useful standards to bring to the next difficult conversation.

If the feedback highlights a planning question, our instructor resources offer further guidance on class structure, cueing and preparation.

Meet the instructor

Jazz is the owner of Bodi Boutique and teaches Pilates and fitness in Millmerran, Queensland. Her training includes Certificate III in Fitness, completed in 2016, Matwork, Reformer and Mat Pilates Instructor Course for Fitness Professionals. Learn more about her background on the About Bodi Boutique page.

References and further reading

  • Business Queensland. Managing customer complaints. Queensland Government guidance on responding to complaints, assigning responsibility and maintaining a complaint-handling process. The fictional class conversations in this article are editorial examples, not reported cases or research findings.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *